Monday, 22 March 2010

Labour slowly getting faster

There will be lots of cynicism about Gordon Brown's speech on getting superfast broadband to everyone in the UK - probably justifiably, but at least it's something. What Labour don't yet seem to be getting is the idea that it's not all about bunging cash at BT.

Jim Knight, the minister responsible for digital inclusion, accepted that the government had to intervene to ensure super-fast broadband reached remote areas of the country. But he told BBC Radio 5 live: "You offer incentives to the market to get to those areas that otherwise they're (HW: presumably meaning BT or Virgin) not going to be able to make a profit out of going to."

This ignores the prospect of community groups "doing it for themselves". Time to release the passion and innovation of the community, surely ?

Wednesday, 17 March 2010

Social TV Forum @ Olympia; The Future of TV & Social Media

I visited the exhibition at this event, looking mainly for interactive TV initiatives with targeted advertising opportunities. I have to say there weren’t many.

About half the stands were for Social Media agencies – all excited at the prospect of taking your money to tell you how to do what you already do. OK, so I didn’t give them a fair chance to convince me that they had the single unique answer for turning social media into a money-spinner but, hey, life’s too short.

I did start to listen to a workshop speaker on ROI for social media. But when I realized I’d been sitting next to him on the train and had seen most of his presentation then, I wandered away. None of it was rocket science anyway. Neat presentational tool called Nudge though.

Of the stalls I talked to people at, the highlights were:
• Monterosa: assuming people are on their laptops while watching TV; allows
games based on program (eg who’s fired next?), plus chat and comments;
could use for product placement opportunities once allowed
• tv genius: web-style search function on STB simplifies search for VOD
content; works with …
• NDS: EPG design platform
• Comment technologies: white-label social networks

So not a lot really.

http://www.social-tv.net/

Monday, 15 March 2010

BSG cost model for fibre

The BSG have appealed for information about fibre costs in order to review the A-M model produced in Sept 2008.

"We are particularly interested to get cost data from actual deployments by local and community projects and other new entrants that may have utilised new methods of deployment, to understand how the costs of deploying fibre may have changed since the report was first published".

At the Newark colloquium I attended, organised by Digital Dales, several people said that the A-M costs were way too high. I'd suggest that if anyone has evidence of this, then they send it to the BSG - contact Peter Shearman (Peter.Shearman@Intellectuk.org]

Friday, 5 March 2010

Broadband Delivery UK

Stephen Timms announced yesterday the formation of a new body, called Broadband Delivery UK, to oversee the 2Mb/s broadband universal service obligation. Long on rhetoric and short on detail - who is on it, what are its terms of reference, what powers will it have- the statement is nonetheless interesting for its reference to a new Analysys Mason report (they must be doing well out of all this !) which describes which communities might be prioritised by the fund. More comments on this once I've read it !

Huw

Thursday, 25 February 2010

Mobile World Congress, Barcelona, Feb 2010

A few observations from meetings, exhibition and atmosphere at the 2010 Mobile World Congress.

Main themes

  • Similar themes and challenges to 2009 – where is the money going to come from and who is it going to go to?
  • Appstores, appstores and more appstores.
  • Not at all clear how operators in mature mobile markets are going to grow revenues in future.
  • Big difference in challenges faced by operators in mature vs less developed mobile markets.
  • A congress in transition –big players participating (or not) more on their own terms.

Network operators

- Common recognition of network capacity issues, plus an increasingly frantic search for cost reduction options – WiFi now reinvented as a low-cost offload; femtocells similarly positioning themselves as unit cost reducer. Being an integrated fixed & mobile operator therefore becomes a cost advantage

- Network spending continues to be slow; mobile operators looking to get more from existing assets and less capex. Possibly some signs of easing since Q4/09.

- 24 operators launched the Wholesale Application Community (WAC) “...to create an ecosystem for the development and distribution of mobile and internet applications irrespective of device or technology”. Trying to build on the OneAPI initiative.

- Not much LTE vs WiMax argument any more. Differences of view on speed of rollout of LTE in Europe. Early LTE deployments in Mid-East and parts of Asia-Pac.

- Operators caught between several rocks (capacity limits, new forms of competition, commoditisation, technology change, regulation of wholesale prices) and a hard place (tariffs with large, effectively “all-you-can-eat” data bundles)

Vendors

- Continued growth of Chinese vendors, now with good track records of delivery, not just price-based contract wins

- Continued revision of vendors’ visibility in the main Halls (very small direct presence from Cisco, IBM, none from HP). More use of surrounding hotels and pavilions.

- Surreal sight of a stand in the infrastructure Hall being taken up by Golla designer bags and phone holders. Maybe someone misunderstood “carriers”, or maybe a belated tribute to Alexander McQueen?

Devices and Operating Systems

- No real excitement on devices. All the action around showing off applications and appstores.

- Latest attempt by Microsoft to be a significant player. Announcement of Windows Phone 7 Series. Not much interest from rest of mobile value chain. More bark by Ballmer than bytes likely to be attracted to the platform.

- There’s a danger that Phone 7 Series will be neither fish (very open and developer-friendly) nor fowl (closed and proprietary and more profit-friendly)

- RIM the biggest visible presence (mainly populated by developers) of all the device manufacturers.

- Samsung launching its own appstore (Bada) – maybe concentrating on AsiaPac developers and market? Also a whole host of alphabet-soup phone ranges and product platforms (eg Monte, Corby, Chat, AMOLED, Wave). Samsung’s consumer electronic strengths, eg screen technology, very apparent, but exhibition was more cluttered than 2009. Maybe Samsung Bada could gain momentum in Asia-Pac?

- Qualcomm gaining more traction through the value chain (starting to stretch into enhanced multimedia, as well as “traditional” strengths like multi-access (HSPA/WiFi) chipsets

- Development of low-end phones for developing markets is becoming more apparent (eg ZTE)

Applications and developers

- Far wider range of applications than previous years. Hard to pick a lead focus of development (cf maps in 2009),

- A whole Hall dedicated to “AppPlanet” – the nearest thing to hype at this year’s event.

- Everyone but everyone touting their own appstore or app development platform.

- Not clear where the money is – RIM suggesting that business-focussed apps have customers willing to pay; Apple and Android more consumer-focussed as larger addressable market

- Big difference in takeup of data services on devices >$200 vs <$200. Maybe an opportunity at this lower end?

- Facebook to develop “Facebook Zero” for lower-end feature phones

- Far less technology development for operators – eg only six small booths on upper level of the technology Hall, last year was crammed. Maybe this is a confirmation of operators’ consolidation and tight spending

- One new feature was the presence of country booths promoting small/medium developers under the nation’s banner eg France, Belgium, South Korea, Ireland. Tea and sympathy in a small booth promoting the UK.

Low Carbon (not)

- Sustainability, low-carbon and green issues are still mainly token gestures

- Most of the vendors’ stands had rotating slide decks about all their acronyms and how they would do a great job for carriers. Each deck had a slide on how green it all was, but it was always the equivalent of a footnote; they may as well have said “our people are our biggest asset”.

- To be slightly more optimistic, there were a few booths around the place that were more dedicated to renewable sources, esp for base stations in developing world, to some extent also for battery recharging. For example, the Powermat wireless charging approach – not yet at the point of really using renewable energy for the charging, but at least getting rid of the multitude of chargers we plug in.

Big beasts in the jungle

- Google - keynote by Eric Schmidt: “Mobile First” is Google’s strategy. Message of “we come in peace”, wearing the sheep’s clothing of “surely openness is good for everyone”. Ironically a demo didn’t work because of connectivity shortage – maybe Google could have paid to have priority on a network for the duration of the demo? Android now shipping 60k devices per day. Maybe "Mobile First" means that Google plans to eat the lunch of the mobile operators before it takes on anyone else?

- Apple – maybe the first signs of some question marks over the Apple experience, eg lack of multitasking, lack of Flash, which could open up market gaps for other platforms

- Microsoft – hardly discussed by anyone. Developers, when asked open question, say they are developing for Apple/BlackBerry first, BlackBerry/Apple second, Android third.

- BlackBerry – major upgrade of visibility in the exhibition hall. Pushing hard to try and build lasting momentum in non-enterprise world

- Huawei/ZTE – a major fixture now at MWC

- Vodafone (representative of operators) – difference between prospects and requirements in developing vs mature markets; complaining strongly about Google’s tanks on lawn; supporter of WAC

Overall mood

- Sense of uncertainty and transition – power balances moving, business models changing rapidly as a result of impact of mobile applications

- No sense of any major meaningful announcements

- Very unBarcelona cold and wet weather, so less energy and buzz on the main avenue

Wednesday, 27 January 2010

BIS consulting on how to spend NextGen Fund

Earlier this month, BIS announced its consultation on how to spend the money raised by the 50p/line Next Generation levy. The 23 questions in the consultation raise serious issues about conflict with free market approaches and chilling investment. The questions also cover the fixed/wireless debate, required speeds, open access, active and passive wholesale products and competitive effects, applications and services, and Government claw-back. In other words, pretty much everything exceot how to select the operators.

BT will be deploying teams of people to respond to this consultation, looking to get its hands on as much of the Fund as it can. No doubt it will argue that only they can provide a network which integrates with the commercially deployed fibre networks - or at least that economies of scale mean they can do it cheapest.

So how can Community Broadband initiatives ensure that they get a fair hearing ? Simple assertions that it is fairer or better will not suffice - what is needed is a thorough analysis and business case which demonstrates that this approach brings the greatest benefits.

Huw Williams
NetStrategics - analysis for telecoms strategy

Tuesday, 1 December 2009

Superfast broadband regulation will differ from first generation broadband

At last week’s Westminster eForum conference on the future of Broadband in the UK, Stuart McIntosh, Ofcom’s Partner for Competition, explained how regulation for superfast broadband would be different from what we had seen before.

In the Telecoms Strategic Review, Ofcom was determined to press for infrastructure competition “at the deepest level possible”. It did this by encouraging Local Loop Unbundling, not least through massive reductions in the wholesale price. The higher levels of investment required necessarily led to a series of takeovers and mergers, and the result in the much-consolidated industry we see today. Ofcom argues that this has led to a much more competitive market, and that competition has led to greater investment.

For superfast broadband, however, they are taking a different view. Firstly, although there is no suggestion of regulatory “forbearance” for BT, Ofcom have said that wholesale prices can reflect risk. And because it sees the economics of fibre roll-out as being more challenging, Ofcom is putting more emphasis on “active” wholesale products , rather than “passive” ones – ie is expecting rather more service provider competition than infrastructure competition.

This leads to a series of interesting questions. How much margin will there be between the passive and active products (as this determines which is the better investment) ? What happens to the deployment of first generation LLU – are these now stranded assets ? If infrastructure competition was so successful first time round, but is not encouraged by favourable pricing this time, does this mean that we will get a less competitive market in superfast broadband ?

Speaking later, Andrew Heaney of TalkTalk insisted that unbundling was still the way to develop competition. It will be interesting to see to what extent he can persuade Ofcom of this.

But, anyway, to what extent will regulation will make a difference to BT’s FTTx investment. Isn’t it far more likely that BT would start blowing fibre very quickly indeed if it saw a big takeup of Virgin Media’s superfast broadband or saw the mobile operators bringing forward their LTE investments. However, neither of those yet seems to be happening in any market-changing way.